Yes, Schedule A defendants have real defenses, and yes, a defendant can sometimes recover attorney's fees. But fees are hard to win, and whether you get them is usually decided in the first 30 days, not at the end of the case, in my opinion.
The short answer
The Seventh Circuit's November 17, 2026 order in Louis Poulsen A/S v. Lightzey shows why. A seller with zero U.S. sales was dismissed with prejudice and still recovered nothing. The court pointed to the seller's own month-long delay in producing its sales records and to an inflated fee bill.
The practical rule is to gather your evidence, give the plaintiff a documented chance to dismiss, and fight promptly if it doesn't. Waiting for a default, or sitting on proof, gives away leverage you cannot get back.
What is a Schedule A case?
A Schedule A case is a trademark, copyright, or design patent lawsuit filed against dozens or hundreds of online sellers at once. The defendants are listed by store name on a sealed attachment, the "Schedule A," instead of in the caption. Most are filed in the Northern District of Illinois.
The plaintiff typically asks the court for an ex parte temporary restraining order (TRO) before any defendant knows about the suit. That order usually freezes the sellers' marketplace and payment accounts on Amazon, Temu, Walmart, eBay, PayPal, and similar platforms. Sellers usually learn they've been sued when their funds stop moving.
The model rests on the plaintiff's account of the facts, accepted before the other side can respond. That's why the plaintiff's evidence, and your speed in rebutting it, matter so much. For the broader picture, see my Schedule A defense page and the Serial Plaintiff Tracker.
What are the defenses to a Schedule A case?
The strongest Schedule A defenses attack whether this court can hear the case against you, whether you were properly joined and served, and whether you infringe at all. Which ones apply depends on your facts, and some must be raised in your first filing or they are lost.
1. Lack of personal jurisdiction
An Illinois federal court can hear a claim against a foreign seller only if the seller aimed its conduct at Illinois. A storefront that merely can be reached from Illinois is not enough. Under NBA Properties v. HANWJH, an actual sale shipped into Illinois can be enough. You raise the defense in a Rule 12(b)(2) motion to dismiss.
Lightzey shows how this plays out. The Seventh Circuit agreed there was no specific jurisdiction where the plaintiff had only cart screenshots of the accused product and one non-infringing order shipped to Illinois. If you have no U.S. or Illinois sales of the accused product, this is often your best defense.
2. Misjoinder
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 20 allows defendants to be sued together only if the claims arise from the same transaction or occurrence. Unrelated sellers who happen to sell similar products often don't meet that test. More N.D. Ill. judges are severing defendants or requiring a showing of a real connection between them.
3. Defective service
Schedule A plaintiffs usually serve by email under a court order. For sellers in countries that are parties to the Hague Service Convention, whether email service is proper is a live and contested question. Defective service can undo a default. I have written about this issue in a Smart Study article for the Illinois Bar Association and elsewhere.
4. No infringement, no counterfeit, or an invalid right
The accused product may not infringe, or may not be a counterfeit at all. A genuine product, a compatible accessory, or a different design is not infringement. The registration or design patent may also be invalid or narrower than the plaintiff claims.
5. An overbroad asset freeze
The freeze is meant to preserve what the plaintiff could actually recover, often the profits from the accused product. Freezing an entire account that holds sales of unrelated products can be challenged. In design patent cases, some judges question whether an equitable asset freeze is available at all when the remedy is money damages.
6. Challenging the TRO or preliminary injunction itself
You can move to dissolve or modify the TRO, contest a preliminary injunction, and challenge a bond set too low to cover the harm. Ex parte relief was granted without your side being heard, and the court can revisit it once you are.
7. Vacating a default
If a default has already been entered, Rules 55(c) and 60(b) allow a court to set it aside for good cause. Doing so costs more and is less certain than appearing on time, which is why I don't recommend waiting.
Can a Schedule A defendant recover attorney's fees?
Sometimes. There are five main routes, and none of them is automatic. Each has its own threshold, and how you conduct the defense from day one decides whether you can meet it.
A fee-shifting statute (Lanham Act § 1117(a), Patent Act § 285, or Copyright Act § 505) requires that you be the prevailing party and, for trademark and patent claims, that the case be "exceptional." This is the main route, and it turns on the record you build.
Rule 11 sanctions require a filing that was frivolous or lacked factual support. They are rarely granted, and the 21-day safe harbor lets the plaintiff withdraw the filing.
Section 1927 requires an attorney who unreasonably and vexatiously multiplied the proceedings. It reaches the attorney, not the client, and courts are reluctant to apply it.
The Rule 65(c) injunction bond requires that you were wrongfully restrained. It is often the easiest route to win, but recovery is capped at the bond.
The court's inherent authority requires bad faith or abuse of the judicial process. It is a last resort with a high bar.
Step one: are you a "prevailing party"?
The fee statutes reward only a prevailing party. A dismissal with prejudice, even a voluntary one by the plaintiff, makes you one in the Seventh Circuit. Lightzey's prevailing-party status was not disputed for that reason.
A dismissal without prejudice usually doesn't make you a prevailing party, because the plaintiff remains free to sue you again. The Seventh Circuit's Live Face on Web decision confirms that a defendant can recover fees after the plaintiff ends its own case with prejudice. It also stresses a "very strong presumption" in favor of fees for a prevailing copyright defendant. But it does not turn a without-prejudice exit into a win.
That is one of the main reasons to press early. A plaintiff that hears from you promptly, and gets no response it can use, often drops you without prejudice and moves on. A defendant who is actively litigating jurisdiction or the merits is in a much better position to insist on a dismissal with prejudice, or to win one.
Step two: is the case "exceptional"?
Under the Lanham Act and the Patent Act, fees go only to the prevailing party in an "exceptional" case. The Seventh Circuit applies the Octane Fitness standard: a case that stands out for the weakness of a party's position or the unreasonable way it was litigated, judged on the totality of the circumstances. District courts have broad discretion, and appeals courts defer to them.
Copyright fees under § 505 use a different, multi-factor test, and the presumption in the defendant's favor is stronger there.
Rule 11: don't count on it
Rule 11 sanctions a filing that is frivolous or lacks evidentiary support. But what feels frivolous to a defendant whose funds were frozen is often not what a court considers frivolous, and for good reason. Courts don't sanction every argument that loses. Nor should they.
Rule 11 also has a 21-day safe harbor. You must serve the motion first, and if the plaintiff withdraws the challenged filing within 21 days, there is no sanction. That's one more reason to put your evidence in front of the plaintiff early.
Section 1927: for cases that drag on
If a case goes on for a long time and fills up with spurious filings, 28 U.S.C. § 1927 lets a court make an attorney personally pay the excess costs and fees caused by unreasonably and vexatiously multiplying the proceedings. It reaches the lawyer, not the client. It is still a request that the court punish someone for bad conduct, and courts are reluctant to grant it.
The TRO bond: easy to reach, but capped
A plaintiff that gets a TRO must post a bond under Rule 65(c). Under Coyne-Delany, a defendant who was wrongfully restrained is presumptively entitled to recover on that bond. In February 2026, an N.D. Ill. judge applied that presumption in a Schedule A case and awarded the full $10,000 bond after the plaintiff voluntarily dismissed. The court refused to go above the bond amount.
So bond recovery may be very easy to get, especially given the presumption. But it is capped at the bond. Bonds in Schedule A cases are often set at amounts that don't come close to covering every defendant, and several defendants may be claiming the same bond. That is another reason to move early: an early claim is safer than a late one.
Case study: Louis Poulsen A/S v. Lightzey (7th Cir. 2026)
On November 17, 2026, the Seventh Circuit affirmed the denial of roughly $142,000 in fees to a Schedule A defendant that had been dismissed with prejudice and had made no U.S. sales. It follows the court's 2022 decision in NBA Properties v. HANWJH, and it is a lesson in how a defendant's own conduct can sink a fee claim.
What happened
May 28, 2024: the court enters a sealed ex parte TRO freezing 436 sellers' accounts, including Lightzey's PayPal account.
July 15, 2024: Lightzey, a Hong Kong seller, learns of the freeze.
Late July 2024: Lightzey tells Poulsen there is no jurisdiction and no basis for the TRO.
August 4, 2024: Poulsen asks for proof of no U.S. sales, and asks again later that month.
September 1, 2024: Lightzey produces sales data showing no U.S. sales of the accused fixture.
September 2, 2024: Poulsen dismisses Lightzey with prejudice.
May 28, 2025: the district court denies Lightzey's fee petition.
November 17, 2026: the Seventh Circuit affirms.
Poulsen's evidence was two screenshots of the accused pendant light in an Illinois shopping cart, never purchased. It also had a completed order for a non-infringing candleholder shipped to Illinois.
Why Lightzey lost its fee claim
Sure, Poulsen knew it didn’t do a test buy. But, the Defendant did not do much to help itself. The court agreed there was no personal jurisdiction, but it did not find the filing unreasonable. Poulsen knew of the infringing listings and at least one Illinois shipment, and the court wouldn't say a test purchase is always required. The court said Lightzey could have been dismissed sooner if it had produced the sales data when Poulsen first asked. Poulsen dismissed the day after it got the data. The court also pointed to the fee bill. Lightzey's lawyers spent about 80 hours on the fee petition, more than they spent getting Lightzey dismissed. I find the amount of time to be, frankly, stunning. The court also declined the invitation from law-professor amici to use the appeal to address Schedule A practice more broadly.
Why the "nonprecedential" label matters
The order is nonprecedential under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 32.1. It can be cited, but it does not bind future panels.
In my view, the Seventh Circuit may have done defendants, generally, and amici, a favor. This appeal came up on bad facts for the defense: a reasonable-looking filing, a fast dismissal, a slow defendant, and a padded bill. A published opinion on that record could have made fee recovery harder for every future Schedule A defendant. Instead, the larger questions remain open, and the amici can come back with a case that has a better record.
How I handle Schedule A defense
I litigate Schedule A cases when they need to be litigated, and when clients want to fight. Lightzey proves a point I make to clients again and again, one many of them would rather not hear: these cases usually require prompt, somewhat aggressive action.
My approach has three steps.
Get the evidence: sales records, shipping data, platform settings, listing details, and anything that shows where you sell and where you don't. All of it gets collected in the first days, not the first month.
Give opposing counsel a chance to dismiss by sending the evidence to plaintiff's counsel with a clear, documented request to dismiss and release the funds.
If they don't dismiss, fight with motions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, motions to dissolve or modify the freeze, and whatever else the case calls for.
If the defendant in Lightzey had done that, the outcome could have been different. Produced on day one, the sales data would have left the plaintiff with no reason to keep the freeze. Had Poulsen then refused to dismiss, the "unreasonable manner of litigation" argument would have been about the plaintiff, not the defendant. Without the delay and the inflated bill, there might have been a fee case.
An example from my practice
In one recent matter, my client was a seller located outside the United States. I wrote to plaintiff's counsel with proof of the client's location and proof, drawn from the listing itself, that the plaintiff should have known the seller wasn't in the U.S. Opposing counsel never responded. I followed up twice. Then I started filing, beginning with a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction.
The settlement terms are confidential. Suffice it to say my client was quite pleased with the result and came out no worse for wear, apart from the stress of the litigation. Every case is different. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
I also represent plaintiffs
I represent brand owners in these cases too, so I know how plaintiffs build them and where they are weak. Given the run of recent Seventh Circuit precedent, though, the economic terms most plaintiffs want to be represented on are not viable for anyone approaching these cases responsibly, in my opinion. Doing it right means test purchases, real jurisdictional evidence, and prompt dismissals when a seller shows it doesn't belong in the case. Brand owners can read how I approach enforcement on my trademark policing and brand protection page.
Mistakes that cost Schedule A defendants leverage
Do not wait for a default. Once a default or default judgment is entered, you're fighting to undo it before you can fight the case. That costs more, it's less certain, and the plaintiff knows it.
Do not sit on evidence. If you have records that prove you don't belong in the case, delay only helps the plaintiff. Lightzey lost its fee claim in large part because of a month-long delay.
Do not answer, counterclaim, or litigate the merits before you raise personal jurisdiction. Under Rule 12(h)(1) the defense is waived if you leave it out of your first Rule 12 motion or your answer, and litigating the merits first can forfeit it by conduct. If you have a jurisdiction argument, it usually belongs in your first filing, though that is a judgment call that depends on the case.
Do not accept a without-prejudice exit before you know what else you could get. A without-prejudice dismissal usually ends any fee claim, and whether it's worth pushing for more depends on your goals and your costs.
Do not let the fee fight cost more than the defense. A fee petition that costs more than the defense itself invites a court to deny it, as happened in Lightzey.
Do not wait to claim the bond. Several defendants may claim the same bond, and the amount rarely covers everyone, so an early claim is safer than a late one.
These are roadmaps, not guarantees. Fees are hard to win, even for a defendant with a strong defense, and the record you build in the first weeks gives a fee claim its best chance.
Frequently asked questions
What fees can a prevailing Schedule A defendant recover?
The main options are fees under the statute behind the claim (Lanham Act § 1117(a), Patent Act § 285, or Copyright Act § 505), Rule 11 sanctions, sanctions under 28 U.S.C. § 1927, and recovery on the TRO bond under Rule 65(c). Each has its own standard, and none is automatic.
Can I get Rule 11 sanctions if the lawsuit against me is frivolous?
Possibly, but don't depend on it. What a frozen-out seller considers frivolous is often not what a court considers frivolous, and courts don't sanction every argument that loses. Rule 11 also gives the plaintiff 21 days to withdraw the filing after you serve your motion.
What is a § 1927 sanction?
Under 28 U.S.C. § 1927, a court can order an attorney who unreasonably and vexatiously multiplies the proceedings to personally pay the excess costs and fees. It fits long cases full of spurious filings. It applies to the lawyer, not the client, and courts are reluctant to award it.
Can I recover on the TRO bond?
Often, yes. In the Seventh Circuit, a wrongfully restrained defendant is presumptively entitled to recover on the bond. But recovery is capped at the bond amount, which in Schedule A cases is often too low to cover every defendant. Several defendants may claim the same bond, so an early claim is safer than a late one.
If the plaintiff dismisses me, am I a prevailing party?
If the dismissal is with prejudice, yes. If it's without prejudice, you usually aren't, because the plaintiff can sue you again. That's one reason to press your defense early instead of hoping the plaintiff drops you.
Should I wait and see whether the plaintiff drops me?
Usually not. Waiting until a default or default judgment is entered loses leverage and makes opposing the case harder and more expensive. Get your evidence together, give the plaintiff a chance to dismiss, and act promptly if it doesn't.
Does Louis Poulsen v. Lightzey mean Schedule A defendants can't get fees?
No. The order is nonprecedential, so it doesn't bind future panels. It turned on its facts: a filing the court found reasonable, a plaintiff that dismissed within a day of getting the evidence, a defendant that delayed producing it, and a fee request the court found inflated.
Will filing an answer or counterclaim hurt my case?
It can, if you have a personal-jurisdiction defense. Litigating the merits first can waive that defense. Talk to counsel before you file anything.
About the author
Jonathan L.A. Phillips merged his boutique IP practice at Phillips & Bathke into Brown, Hay & Stephens, LLP, where he handles intellectual property and federal litigation. He represents both online sellers and brand owners in Schedule A cases in the Northern District of Illinois and elsewhere.
Named in a Schedule A case? Time matters. Contact Jonathan to talk about your options before a default is entered.
Related service: Schedule A defense and litigation. Part of the Serial Plaintiff Tracker.
Jonathan L.A. Phillips, Brown, Hay & Stephens, LLP. Last reviewed November 2026. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney advertising.