BMI, ASCAP, SESAC, or GMR Demand Letter? Music Licensing Defense for Bars, Restaurants, and VenuesYou had live music at your bar. Now you have a demand letter from BMI.
BMI, ASCAP, SESAC, and Global Music Rights (GMR) license the public performance of music for the songwriters and publishers they represent, and they pursue venues that play music without a license. Most of these disputes resolve without a lawsuit if they are handled promptly. Jonathan Phillips represents bars, restaurants, and venues nationwide in music licensing and signal piracy matters.
Who sends these: BMI, ASCAP, SESAC, and GMR, directly or through counsel
What they claim: Copyrighted songs performed publicly, live or recorded, without a license
Damages the statute allows: $750 to $30,000 per song; up to $150,000 per song if willful (17 U.S.C. § 504(c))
What usually resolves it: A license going forward plus a negotiated amount for past performances
Are these organizations legitimate?
Yes. A business that plays copyrighted music publicly generally needs licenses, and these organizations collect those fees. The question is not whether they exist but what you actually owe.
Does one license cover everything?
No. Each organization licenses a different catalog of songwriters, so a BMI license does not cover ASCAP, SESAC, or GMR songs. A venue that plays a wide mix of music usually needs more than one.
What decides how much I owe?
What was performed, and which organization represents those songs.
Whether any licenses were in place at the time, even partial ones.
Your history, including earlier notices or license offers you did not answer, which bears on willfulness.
What they can prove, usually through an investigator's song list from a specific night.
What to do in the first week
Do not sign a license or call the organization until you know what you need.
Gather any licenses you have, including those held by a jukebox or background-music service.
List what music you play: live bands, DJs, streaming, TV, and radio.
Note every earlier letter from any of the four organizations.
Talk to counsel before you respond.
Frequently asked questions
Does a streaming subscription like Spotify cover my bar? Usually not. Consumer accounts are for personal use; commercial background-music services may include licenses, so check the terms.
The band chose the songs. Am I still responsible? Usually yes; the venue is typically treated as responsible for performances on its premises.
Can I just stop playing music? That limits future exposure, but it does not resolve past performances.
What does it cost? Flat fees are available for most music licensing matters.
Jonathan L.A. Phillips, Brown, Hay & Stephens, LLP. Part of the Serial Plaintiff Tracker. Last reviewed October 2026.